There are stories that shouldn’t have to be retold — stories that never belonged to headlines or horror shows in the first place. Evelyn Hartley’s is one of them. On October 24th of 1953, fifteen-year-old Evelyn agreed to babysit for a La Crosse, Wisconsin family — the Rasmussens. It was a favor to a friend who couldn’t go that evening. The Rasmussens’ daughter was sleeping soundly upstairs when Evelyn disappeared into the night. When the parents returned, the house was dark.